Skip to content
Sell With D&B

You Own It.We Sell It.

Consigning your cards should not feel like a gamble. No wondering where your cards are. No surprise fees. No waiting for answers or payments. Clear updates. Transparent fees. Fast payouts. We built D&B to make consignment work the way collectors deserve.

Start a SubmissionSee the Fees
This month’s intake— / —

We take a limited number of lots each month because D&B verifies and photographs every one in hand.

In Plain English

What Consignment Means

Consignment is simple: you own a card, we sell it for you, and we take a percentage of what it sells for. That is the whole idea.

You keep ownership the entire time. We are your selling agent, not a buyer — we are not purchasing your card from you. If it does not sell, it is still yours and you decide what happens next.

What you are handing over is the work: photographing it properly, writing the listing, putting it in front of collectors who are already bidding, taking the payment, packing it safely and shipping it insured. That is what the 5% pays for.

Versus selling it yourself

  • Photography

    Your phone, your kitchen tableShot in hand, same lighting every time

  • Reach

    Whoever happens to scroll pastCollectors already in the room, bidding

  • Payment risk

    YoursOurs — card on file required to bid

  • Getting cards to us

    n/aInsured label we buy, or drop off in Plain City

  • Packing & shipping

    Your time, your liabilityWe pack, insure and ship every lot

  • If it goes wrong

    You argue with a strangerWe handle the dispute
No Surprises

Five Percent. That's It.

Simple fees. No surprises. Buyers pay a 15% premium, already included in the displayed price. Sellers pay just 5%. No listing fees. No photography fees. No monthly fees. No sale, no fee.

A card that hammers at $1,000

Buyer is charged
$1,150.00
Hammer price
$1,000.00
Buyer premium (15%, paid by the buyer)
$150.00
Our commission (5%)
−$50.00
Shipping label we advanced
−$12.60
Your net proceeds
$937.40

Nothing up front

We buy the shipping label and the insurance and deduct it from your proceeds. You never send us money.

No fee if it does not sell

If your lot does not sell, you owe us nothing. Relist it one more time at no charge, or have your card returned to you. Your card. Your choice.

Every cent itemized

Your payout statement shows the hammer, the commission, any shipping advanced, and the net. No line items you have to ask about.

How It Works

Submission to Payout

Roughly five minutes of your time per card, then we take it from there. Every stage is logged with a timestamp and a photograph you can see from your account.

  1. Submit your cards

    5 min per card

    Photos, grader, certification number, the starting price you want, and a recent comparable sale. Submit as many as you like in one go.

  2. D&B reviews each one

    Within 5 days

    Card by card, not all-or-nothing. Each is accepted, declined, or countered with a different starting price you are free to turn down. We only take a set number of lots a month, so acceptance is not automatic.

  3. Ship it insured, or drop it off

    You choose

    We buy a USPS label with insurance and deduct the cost from your proceeds. Cards above the Priority ceiling go Registered Mail. Local? Bring them by appointment.

  4. We verify and photograph

    Within 48 hours of arrival

    The certification number is checked against the grading company's database and the holder is inspected. Then D&B photographs it in hand. If anything does not match your submission, you hear that day with pictures.

  5. Preview in The Cage

    Before bidding opens

    Your card starts gaining watchers before the auction goes live. More eyes. More interest. More competition when bidding opens.

  6. The auction runs

    3 to 10 days

    Published closing time, anti-snipe protection, hard cap on extensions. You watch views, watchers and bids in real time — the same numbers we see.

  7. You get paid

    7 days after delivery

    Once the card arrives and the dispute window closes, your funds are yours. Withdraw your money or put it toward your next card. Your choice.

What We Take

Graded Only. No Exceptions.

We accept

  • PSA, Titan, BGS, SGC and CGC — verified automatically
  • Any sport, plus TCG and non-sport
  • Vintage and modern
  • Cards with an intact holder and a readable cert number
  • Single cards or a whole collection

We do not accept

  • Raw cards, in any condition
  • Cracked, tampered or resealed holders
  • Cert numbers that cannot be verified
  • Cards you do not own outright or have authority to sell
  • Reprints, reproductions or anything of questionable provenance

Not graded yet? Get them slabbed first and come back — we are happy to point you toward the right grader for what you have.

While We Have It

Your Card, Accounted For.

Photographed by D&B, in hand

Consistent, professional photography gives every card the presentation it deserves. Clear images. Accurate details. No guesswork.

Insured in our custody

Covered by commercial insurance from the moment it arrives until the moment it ships. Every movement logged with a photograph.

Live status, not a status update

Real numbers. Real results. Full transparency. Views, watchers, bids and the current price, in real time — plus a notification at every stage: received, verified, listed, first bid, reserve met, final hour, sold, paid.

Paid on a schedule

Funds are available 7 days after confirmed delivery. Withdraw to your bank or use your balance to bid. Every fee is clear. Every dollar is accounted for.

Ready When You Are.

Submitting costs nothing and commits you to nothing. If we accept a card and you do not like the terms, you walk away.

Start a SubmissionRead the Consignment Agreement